Does wishing a spell glyph into existence also require casting the stored spell?
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
Suppose I want to use wish to cast an 8th-level glyph of warding (for free) and store a spell in it. Do I still need to supply the spell to be stored by casting it using another one of my spell slots? If so, this would limit me to only storing spells I can cast, and would require expending a second spell slot as normal.
Or does the wish spell take care of all of that, allowing me to wish the ward into existence with only a 9th level spell slot and choose any valid spell from any class's spell list?
dnd-5e spells wish
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
Suppose I want to use wish to cast an 8th-level glyph of warding (for free) and store a spell in it. Do I still need to supply the spell to be stored by casting it using another one of my spell slots? If so, this would limit me to only storing spells I can cast, and would require expending a second spell slot as normal.
Or does the wish spell take care of all of that, allowing me to wish the ward into existence with only a 9th level spell slot and choose any valid spell from any class's spell list?
dnd-5e spells wish
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
add a comment |
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
Suppose I want to use wish to cast an 8th-level glyph of warding (for free) and store a spell in it. Do I still need to supply the spell to be stored by casting it using another one of my spell slots? If so, this would limit me to only storing spells I can cast, and would require expending a second spell slot as normal.
Or does the wish spell take care of all of that, allowing me to wish the ward into existence with only a 9th level spell slot and choose any valid spell from any class's spell list?
dnd-5e spells wish
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
Suppose I want to use wish to cast an 8th-level glyph of warding (for free) and store a spell in it. Do I still need to supply the spell to be stored by casting it using another one of my spell slots? If so, this would limit me to only storing spells I can cast, and would require expending a second spell slot as normal.
Or does the wish spell take care of all of that, allowing me to wish the ward into existence with only a 9th level spell slot and choose any valid spell from any class's spell list?
dnd-5e spells wish
dnd-5e spells wish
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
edited Nov 30 at 19:51
Rubiksmoose
46.2k6232353
46.2k6232353
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
asked Nov 30 at 19:06
Ryan Thompson
5,24111852
5,24111852
add a comment |
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
20
down vote
accepted
It depends on how you use the Wish
Wish has, principally, two different classes of use:
- Duplicate the effects of a spell
- Cause something else to happen; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell
This means that, in practice, you have two options for bringing a Glyph of Warding into existence:
- Duplicate a Glyph of Warding spell exactly as written, meaning you still need to use the second spell slot and are limited to providing only spells that you are capable of preparing (and have prepared at the time you cast Wish
- Create a Glyph of Warding with whatever spell you want (and maybe an additional effect? It's your wish...), no longer needing to spend the second spell slot or have the spell prepared; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell.
There is one wrinkle in the former use of the Wish though:
The basic use of this spell is to duplicate any other spell of 8th level or lower. You don't need to meet any requirements in that spell, including costly components. The spell simply takes effect.
What, exactly, constitutes a "Requirement ignored by Wish" is the subject of considerable debate. Based on that post, Requirements is here intended to refer to things like cast-time, material components, spell lists, preparation, etc.. I don't think it would permit you to ignore the requirements to
- Have the spell that you plan to place within the Glyph prepared
- Be capable of spending the necessary spell slot to cast the spell you plan to place in the Glyph
Unless, of course, your DM decides to rule that those requirements can be handwaved as part of the "ignore the spell's requirements" stipulation.
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
20
down vote
accepted
It depends on how you use the Wish
Wish has, principally, two different classes of use:
- Duplicate the effects of a spell
- Cause something else to happen; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell
This means that, in practice, you have two options for bringing a Glyph of Warding into existence:
- Duplicate a Glyph of Warding spell exactly as written, meaning you still need to use the second spell slot and are limited to providing only spells that you are capable of preparing (and have prepared at the time you cast Wish
- Create a Glyph of Warding with whatever spell you want (and maybe an additional effect? It's your wish...), no longer needing to spend the second spell slot or have the spell prepared; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell.
There is one wrinkle in the former use of the Wish though:
The basic use of this spell is to duplicate any other spell of 8th level or lower. You don't need to meet any requirements in that spell, including costly components. The spell simply takes effect.
What, exactly, constitutes a "Requirement ignored by Wish" is the subject of considerable debate. Based on that post, Requirements is here intended to refer to things like cast-time, material components, spell lists, preparation, etc.. I don't think it would permit you to ignore the requirements to
- Have the spell that you plan to place within the Glyph prepared
- Be capable of spending the necessary spell slot to cast the spell you plan to place in the Glyph
Unless, of course, your DM decides to rule that those requirements can be handwaved as part of the "ignore the spell's requirements" stipulation.
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
add a comment |
up vote
20
down vote
accepted
It depends on how you use the Wish
Wish has, principally, two different classes of use:
- Duplicate the effects of a spell
- Cause something else to happen; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell
This means that, in practice, you have two options for bringing a Glyph of Warding into existence:
- Duplicate a Glyph of Warding spell exactly as written, meaning you still need to use the second spell slot and are limited to providing only spells that you are capable of preparing (and have prepared at the time you cast Wish
- Create a Glyph of Warding with whatever spell you want (and maybe an additional effect? It's your wish...), no longer needing to spend the second spell slot or have the spell prepared; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell.
There is one wrinkle in the former use of the Wish though:
The basic use of this spell is to duplicate any other spell of 8th level or lower. You don't need to meet any requirements in that spell, including costly components. The spell simply takes effect.
What, exactly, constitutes a "Requirement ignored by Wish" is the subject of considerable debate. Based on that post, Requirements is here intended to refer to things like cast-time, material components, spell lists, preparation, etc.. I don't think it would permit you to ignore the requirements to
- Have the spell that you plan to place within the Glyph prepared
- Be capable of spending the necessary spell slot to cast the spell you plan to place in the Glyph
Unless, of course, your DM decides to rule that those requirements can be handwaved as part of the "ignore the spell's requirements" stipulation.
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
add a comment |
up vote
20
down vote
accepted
up vote
20
down vote
accepted
It depends on how you use the Wish
Wish has, principally, two different classes of use:
- Duplicate the effects of a spell
- Cause something else to happen; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell
This means that, in practice, you have two options for bringing a Glyph of Warding into existence:
- Duplicate a Glyph of Warding spell exactly as written, meaning you still need to use the second spell slot and are limited to providing only spells that you are capable of preparing (and have prepared at the time you cast Wish
- Create a Glyph of Warding with whatever spell you want (and maybe an additional effect? It's your wish...), no longer needing to spend the second spell slot or have the spell prepared; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell.
There is one wrinkle in the former use of the Wish though:
The basic use of this spell is to duplicate any other spell of 8th level or lower. You don't need to meet any requirements in that spell, including costly components. The spell simply takes effect.
What, exactly, constitutes a "Requirement ignored by Wish" is the subject of considerable debate. Based on that post, Requirements is here intended to refer to things like cast-time, material components, spell lists, preparation, etc.. I don't think it would permit you to ignore the requirements to
- Have the spell that you plan to place within the Glyph prepared
- Be capable of spending the necessary spell slot to cast the spell you plan to place in the Glyph
Unless, of course, your DM decides to rule that those requirements can be handwaved as part of the "ignore the spell's requirements" stipulation.
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
It depends on how you use the Wish
Wish has, principally, two different classes of use:
- Duplicate the effects of a spell
- Cause something else to happen; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell
This means that, in practice, you have two options for bringing a Glyph of Warding into existence:
- Duplicate a Glyph of Warding spell exactly as written, meaning you still need to use the second spell slot and are limited to providing only spells that you are capable of preparing (and have prepared at the time you cast Wish
- Create a Glyph of Warding with whatever spell you want (and maybe an additional effect? It's your wish...), no longer needing to spend the second spell slot or have the spell prepared; take backlash damage from the Stress of the spell.
There is one wrinkle in the former use of the Wish though:
The basic use of this spell is to duplicate any other spell of 8th level or lower. You don't need to meet any requirements in that spell, including costly components. The spell simply takes effect.
What, exactly, constitutes a "Requirement ignored by Wish" is the subject of considerable debate. Based on that post, Requirements is here intended to refer to things like cast-time, material components, spell lists, preparation, etc.. I don't think it would permit you to ignore the requirements to
- Have the spell that you plan to place within the Glyph prepared
- Be capable of spending the necessary spell slot to cast the spell you plan to place in the Glyph
Unless, of course, your DM decides to rule that those requirements can be handwaved as part of the "ignore the spell's requirements" stipulation.
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
edited Nov 30 at 19:42
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
answered Nov 30 at 19:30
Xirema
14.2k24087
14.2k24087
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
add a comment |
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
I probably could have been a bit more explicit about it, but I'm specifically asking about the "duplicate an 8th level spell" usage.
– Ryan Thompson
Nov 30 at 19:44
4
4
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
@RyanThompson Which is fair; I'm pointing out however that there's nothing stopping you from using the "do something else" portion of a Wish's power to "duplicate a spell, except for this one aspect of the spell I want to change..."
– Xirema
Nov 30 at 19:46
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f136580%2fdoes-wishing-a-spell-glyph-into-existence-also-require-casting-the-stored-spell%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
