If you can be “discombobulated”, is it possible to be “combobulated”?
up vote
14
down vote
favorite
I've often heard the word "discombobulated" used. But I've never heard of something being "combobulated", and it's not in any dictionary I've looked at. If "combobulated" is not word, where did "discombobulated" come from?
etymology language-evolution
add a comment |
up vote
14
down vote
favorite
I've often heard the word "discombobulated" used. But I've never heard of something being "combobulated", and it's not in any dictionary I've looked at. If "combobulated" is not word, where did "discombobulated" come from?
etymology language-evolution
4
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
1
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15
add a comment |
up vote
14
down vote
favorite
up vote
14
down vote
favorite
I've often heard the word "discombobulated" used. But I've never heard of something being "combobulated", and it's not in any dictionary I've looked at. If "combobulated" is not word, where did "discombobulated" come from?
etymology language-evolution
I've often heard the word "discombobulated" used. But I've never heard of something being "combobulated", and it's not in any dictionary I've looked at. If "combobulated" is not word, where did "discombobulated" come from?
etymology language-evolution
etymology language-evolution
edited Dec 10 at 18:45
Jackspace
33
33
asked Aug 18 '11 at 3:04
Grant Paul
171116
171116
4
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
1
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15
add a comment |
4
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
1
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15
4
4
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
1
1
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15
add a comment |
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
up vote
8
down vote
It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.
It certainly doesn't derive from some pre-existing word combobulate. I think normally you'd be understood if you tried to use that 'back-formation', but I don't think it will catch on.
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
In my opinion, it comes from the Italian word "scombussolato", which has the same definition and literally means "of someone whose compass is discomposed or has none". Bussola being the word for compass in Italian.
The alteration of the original word to "discombobulated" follows the classic pattern of enunciation alteration that follow Italian words into English language.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
I can not speak to previous answers. My opinion is based on personal experience. I first heard combobulate/discombobulate (both terms) in the late 1940s from my 60-year-old grandfather, when I was four. On being asked, he could not recall its source.
Several days later, he came to me with a crumbling old letter he had received as a very young boy (mid 1890s), passed down from his grandmother. It was dated in 1823 and written by his great grandfather, and it contained the word combobulate, meaning (from the sense in which it was used) “to make order”.
At the time of writing it, the elder gentleman was in his mid-60s, so I am left to presume that the term goes back a good deal further.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
I am going to suggest taking your heads out of the history books and look to the source of many recently added dictionary words' sources...the TV! LOL! Although I do not recall completely which episode this was, I have used this word since learning it when I was a mere 5 or so years old with my first being introduced to it while watching the original Astro Boy animated TV series, in which there was an episode he was being asked about his origins and first memories, and he replied with "The first thing I remembered was waking up in the Ministry of Science, on a busted up lab table. At the time, I had no idea what was going on. I was kind of…discombobulated." And I remember thinking how cool that BIG word was, and latched on to using it at every applicable opportunity.
Of course this is not necessarily the true source of the word, but certainly what brought it into the mainstream consciousness, and since these episodes were primarily based upon a 1950's comic book series, it would not surprise me if this were indeed the first ever use of it, since looking at the Dictionary.com timeline for its use, it shows exactly near the end of the 50's to begin being used, and then steadily rise in popularity of use as it CONTINUES to still to this day!!
When I used this word in an email and since my spell checker did not ask for override, I searched in surprise to find it was indeed a dictionary word, so I clicked on dictionary.com's etymology tab which was rather disappointing beyond the said timeline reported of its use which in turn brought me here to find out when this was officially became a "dictionary word" and when I saw all of these presumptuous but EDUCATED guesses of its formulation...
I thought the source of my first experience of this word's usage may contribute useful information to pinning an accurate origin or to find the actual formation of the word for its use.
Although... I don't think it will be found in "Astro Boy's origins", for being a Japanese language based iconic character, for obvious translation limitations, (which MAYBE, opened the way to substitute for a Japanese word lacking an English equivalent? If the original Japanese word translated only partially to disconcerting or something like this and and needed i t to sound "Robotically advanced but easy for children to grasp the context...just speculating on potential creative thought processes!)that became the first true "anime'" show in the US, I think it would MOST likely be "Frederik L. Schodt" who will provide any validation of this...he is the person who adapted the Japanese story lines to be suitable for the American "elementary level schoolboy audience" it was targeted to be received by...and I sure was one of them!
I hope my brief history is not too long for this page to publish! My apologies if it is, if you need to edit it without losing context, I'm okay with it, I just hoped to ensure that proper crediting of this word fall on the possibly living originator or the popularizing of its use!
Daniel
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Here's a definition.
"the 'nineties' refers of course to the 1890s
Supplement to Rural Dialect of Grant County, Indiana, in the 'nineties
Waldo Lee McAtee, 1942 - Americanisms
discombobulate, v., put out of order, upset plans.
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RZQVAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgpMAA
... and here's a definition of sorts from a book written in 1893.
Half-hours with Jimmieboy
John Kendrick Bangs, R.H. Russell, 1893
"Well, here's a thing I don't know about," said Jimmieboy. "What is
'to alarm?'" "To frighten-to scare-to discombobulate."
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0_5DAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgxMAI
Before that we have the following from Going on a Mission by Paul Cobden, 1871
He told the cook what he'd done, and said it would 'perfectly discombobulate Maam Prole to miss her Bible...'
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=YT0wAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA32&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElazEh5bfAhWLQRUIHa_yDRAQ6AEIOjAE#v=onepage&q=%22discombobulate%22&f=false
I haven't been able to get back any further than that so I expect it is just a comical-sounding dialect word that someone either made up or mis-heard.
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
It's a joke word based on "discomfort", "disconcert" etc which are based on the french 'dis' meaning apart or opposite.
So if discomfort is undo-comfort and discombobulate is from the same sense you can have combolbulate as the opposite of whatever discombobulate is
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
"Discombobulate" is similar to "flabbergasted" and "unwittingly".
These are examples of words that spontaneously arose--a phenomenon more frequently observed in the recent flash of social media and broadcast television. Small, even unintentional expressions can (and have) quickly caught on because they're likable and catchy.
It's the affair of language. Novelty bears offspring too.
Discombobulate is somewhat similar in concept to "dis-member" and "re-member", for while "combobulate" could come into usage, "recombobulate" is more likely since both relate a sense of "being done unto" rather than "doing unto another". Dismember and remember are not pure opposites, but conceptually relate since "memory can be altered and refashioned to serve slightly different purposes than it may have at the actual event" just as "dismemberment proves to alter and refashion so that service can no longer be rendered appropriately".
For example, one does not recapitulate in any related way that one capitulates, even though the capitalist may continue to capitalize on the edicts of the capital in a move toward capitulation for personal gain. Recapitulation will ever retain a personal note, for it is championed by the subjective, forgivable rendering. And so it may be with discombobulation--it is a personal event and, so far, may be unrelated to one's previous state.
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
to dismember someone you remove their limbs yes? so to member them - that does not mean to reattach the limbs does it. Remove the members (limbs) but you cannot then limb or member them and expect that to mean the opposite of dismember, so not every dis, has an exact opposite, there are some exceptions. I am inclined to think same exception applies to discombobulate.
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
http://www.definition-of.com/Combobulate
According to definition.com, COMBOBULATE is a word.
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
add a comment |
protected by tchrist♦ Jan 2 '16 at 2:27
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
8
down vote
It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.
It certainly doesn't derive from some pre-existing word combobulate. I think normally you'd be understood if you tried to use that 'back-formation', but I don't think it will catch on.
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.
It certainly doesn't derive from some pre-existing word combobulate. I think normally you'd be understood if you tried to use that 'back-formation', but I don't think it will catch on.
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
add a comment |
up vote
8
down vote
up vote
8
down vote
It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.
It certainly doesn't derive from some pre-existing word combobulate. I think normally you'd be understood if you tried to use that 'back-formation', but I don't think it will catch on.
It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.
It certainly doesn't derive from some pre-existing word combobulate. I think normally you'd be understood if you tried to use that 'back-formation', but I don't think it will catch on.
edited Aug 20 '11 at 23:07
answered Aug 18 '11 at 3:14
FumbleFingers
119k32242422
119k32242422
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
add a comment |
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
Maybe it will catch on. This is from urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=combobulated. Yo dogg, Mr. Dan really combobulates calculus! Fo shizzle D!
– mmesser314
Feb 5 '15 at 14:47
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
The OED (note: the OED is behind a paywall, you may need institutional access or a subscription to follow the link) puts the first use of "discombobulate" (as a verb) around 1825. The section on etymology basically comes down to "origin unknown", but that it was possibly built along the rules of humorous slang of the time, and in analogy to the words FF cites. Basically, the OED confirms FF' answer. The OED has no entry for "combobulated," which indicates that it isn't often used (though I think that you would be understood if you used it).
– user300358
May 25 at 13:57
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
In my opinion, it comes from the Italian word "scombussolato", which has the same definition and literally means "of someone whose compass is discomposed or has none". Bussola being the word for compass in Italian.
The alteration of the original word to "discombobulated" follows the classic pattern of enunciation alteration that follow Italian words into English language.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
In my opinion, it comes from the Italian word "scombussolato", which has the same definition and literally means "of someone whose compass is discomposed or has none". Bussola being the word for compass in Italian.
The alteration of the original word to "discombobulated" follows the classic pattern of enunciation alteration that follow Italian words into English language.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
up vote
6
down vote
In my opinion, it comes from the Italian word "scombussolato", which has the same definition and literally means "of someone whose compass is discomposed or has none". Bussola being the word for compass in Italian.
The alteration of the original word to "discombobulated" follows the classic pattern of enunciation alteration that follow Italian words into English language.
In my opinion, it comes from the Italian word "scombussolato", which has the same definition and literally means "of someone whose compass is discomposed or has none". Bussola being the word for compass in Italian.
The alteration of the original word to "discombobulated" follows the classic pattern of enunciation alteration that follow Italian words into English language.
edited Jan 28 '15 at 19:23
Loong
169312
169312
answered Jul 1 '14 at 19:10
alex
7711
7711
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
I can not speak to previous answers. My opinion is based on personal experience. I first heard combobulate/discombobulate (both terms) in the late 1940s from my 60-year-old grandfather, when I was four. On being asked, he could not recall its source.
Several days later, he came to me with a crumbling old letter he had received as a very young boy (mid 1890s), passed down from his grandmother. It was dated in 1823 and written by his great grandfather, and it contained the word combobulate, meaning (from the sense in which it was used) “to make order”.
At the time of writing it, the elder gentleman was in his mid-60s, so I am left to presume that the term goes back a good deal further.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
I can not speak to previous answers. My opinion is based on personal experience. I first heard combobulate/discombobulate (both terms) in the late 1940s from my 60-year-old grandfather, when I was four. On being asked, he could not recall its source.
Several days later, he came to me with a crumbling old letter he had received as a very young boy (mid 1890s), passed down from his grandmother. It was dated in 1823 and written by his great grandfather, and it contained the word combobulate, meaning (from the sense in which it was used) “to make order”.
At the time of writing it, the elder gentleman was in his mid-60s, so I am left to presume that the term goes back a good deal further.
add a comment |
up vote
6
down vote
up vote
6
down vote
I can not speak to previous answers. My opinion is based on personal experience. I first heard combobulate/discombobulate (both terms) in the late 1940s from my 60-year-old grandfather, when I was four. On being asked, he could not recall its source.
Several days later, he came to me with a crumbling old letter he had received as a very young boy (mid 1890s), passed down from his grandmother. It was dated in 1823 and written by his great grandfather, and it contained the word combobulate, meaning (from the sense in which it was used) “to make order”.
At the time of writing it, the elder gentleman was in his mid-60s, so I am left to presume that the term goes back a good deal further.
I can not speak to previous answers. My opinion is based on personal experience. I first heard combobulate/discombobulate (both terms) in the late 1940s from my 60-year-old grandfather, when I was four. On being asked, he could not recall its source.
Several days later, he came to me with a crumbling old letter he had received as a very young boy (mid 1890s), passed down from his grandmother. It was dated in 1823 and written by his great grandfather, and it contained the word combobulate, meaning (from the sense in which it was used) “to make order”.
At the time of writing it, the elder gentleman was in his mid-60s, so I am left to presume that the term goes back a good deal further.
edited Jul 28 '15 at 3:49
tchrist♦
108k28290463
108k28290463
answered Jul 28 '15 at 2:13
Tech Writer
6911
6911
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
I am going to suggest taking your heads out of the history books and look to the source of many recently added dictionary words' sources...the TV! LOL! Although I do not recall completely which episode this was, I have used this word since learning it when I was a mere 5 or so years old with my first being introduced to it while watching the original Astro Boy animated TV series, in which there was an episode he was being asked about his origins and first memories, and he replied with "The first thing I remembered was waking up in the Ministry of Science, on a busted up lab table. At the time, I had no idea what was going on. I was kind of…discombobulated." And I remember thinking how cool that BIG word was, and latched on to using it at every applicable opportunity.
Of course this is not necessarily the true source of the word, but certainly what brought it into the mainstream consciousness, and since these episodes were primarily based upon a 1950's comic book series, it would not surprise me if this were indeed the first ever use of it, since looking at the Dictionary.com timeline for its use, it shows exactly near the end of the 50's to begin being used, and then steadily rise in popularity of use as it CONTINUES to still to this day!!
When I used this word in an email and since my spell checker did not ask for override, I searched in surprise to find it was indeed a dictionary word, so I clicked on dictionary.com's etymology tab which was rather disappointing beyond the said timeline reported of its use which in turn brought me here to find out when this was officially became a "dictionary word" and when I saw all of these presumptuous but EDUCATED guesses of its formulation...
I thought the source of my first experience of this word's usage may contribute useful information to pinning an accurate origin or to find the actual formation of the word for its use.
Although... I don't think it will be found in "Astro Boy's origins", for being a Japanese language based iconic character, for obvious translation limitations, (which MAYBE, opened the way to substitute for a Japanese word lacking an English equivalent? If the original Japanese word translated only partially to disconcerting or something like this and and needed i t to sound "Robotically advanced but easy for children to grasp the context...just speculating on potential creative thought processes!)that became the first true "anime'" show in the US, I think it would MOST likely be "Frederik L. Schodt" who will provide any validation of this...he is the person who adapted the Japanese story lines to be suitable for the American "elementary level schoolboy audience" it was targeted to be received by...and I sure was one of them!
I hope my brief history is not too long for this page to publish! My apologies if it is, if you need to edit it without losing context, I'm okay with it, I just hoped to ensure that proper crediting of this word fall on the possibly living originator or the popularizing of its use!
Daniel
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
I am going to suggest taking your heads out of the history books and look to the source of many recently added dictionary words' sources...the TV! LOL! Although I do not recall completely which episode this was, I have used this word since learning it when I was a mere 5 or so years old with my first being introduced to it while watching the original Astro Boy animated TV series, in which there was an episode he was being asked about his origins and first memories, and he replied with "The first thing I remembered was waking up in the Ministry of Science, on a busted up lab table. At the time, I had no idea what was going on. I was kind of…discombobulated." And I remember thinking how cool that BIG word was, and latched on to using it at every applicable opportunity.
Of course this is not necessarily the true source of the word, but certainly what brought it into the mainstream consciousness, and since these episodes were primarily based upon a 1950's comic book series, it would not surprise me if this were indeed the first ever use of it, since looking at the Dictionary.com timeline for its use, it shows exactly near the end of the 50's to begin being used, and then steadily rise in popularity of use as it CONTINUES to still to this day!!
When I used this word in an email and since my spell checker did not ask for override, I searched in surprise to find it was indeed a dictionary word, so I clicked on dictionary.com's etymology tab which was rather disappointing beyond the said timeline reported of its use which in turn brought me here to find out when this was officially became a "dictionary word" and when I saw all of these presumptuous but EDUCATED guesses of its formulation...
I thought the source of my first experience of this word's usage may contribute useful information to pinning an accurate origin or to find the actual formation of the word for its use.
Although... I don't think it will be found in "Astro Boy's origins", for being a Japanese language based iconic character, for obvious translation limitations, (which MAYBE, opened the way to substitute for a Japanese word lacking an English equivalent? If the original Japanese word translated only partially to disconcerting or something like this and and needed i t to sound "Robotically advanced but easy for children to grasp the context...just speculating on potential creative thought processes!)that became the first true "anime'" show in the US, I think it would MOST likely be "Frederik L. Schodt" who will provide any validation of this...he is the person who adapted the Japanese story lines to be suitable for the American "elementary level schoolboy audience" it was targeted to be received by...and I sure was one of them!
I hope my brief history is not too long for this page to publish! My apologies if it is, if you need to edit it without losing context, I'm okay with it, I just hoped to ensure that proper crediting of this word fall on the possibly living originator or the popularizing of its use!
Daniel
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
I am going to suggest taking your heads out of the history books and look to the source of many recently added dictionary words' sources...the TV! LOL! Although I do not recall completely which episode this was, I have used this word since learning it when I was a mere 5 or so years old with my first being introduced to it while watching the original Astro Boy animated TV series, in which there was an episode he was being asked about his origins and first memories, and he replied with "The first thing I remembered was waking up in the Ministry of Science, on a busted up lab table. At the time, I had no idea what was going on. I was kind of…discombobulated." And I remember thinking how cool that BIG word was, and latched on to using it at every applicable opportunity.
Of course this is not necessarily the true source of the word, but certainly what brought it into the mainstream consciousness, and since these episodes were primarily based upon a 1950's comic book series, it would not surprise me if this were indeed the first ever use of it, since looking at the Dictionary.com timeline for its use, it shows exactly near the end of the 50's to begin being used, and then steadily rise in popularity of use as it CONTINUES to still to this day!!
When I used this word in an email and since my spell checker did not ask for override, I searched in surprise to find it was indeed a dictionary word, so I clicked on dictionary.com's etymology tab which was rather disappointing beyond the said timeline reported of its use which in turn brought me here to find out when this was officially became a "dictionary word" and when I saw all of these presumptuous but EDUCATED guesses of its formulation...
I thought the source of my first experience of this word's usage may contribute useful information to pinning an accurate origin or to find the actual formation of the word for its use.
Although... I don't think it will be found in "Astro Boy's origins", for being a Japanese language based iconic character, for obvious translation limitations, (which MAYBE, opened the way to substitute for a Japanese word lacking an English equivalent? If the original Japanese word translated only partially to disconcerting or something like this and and needed i t to sound "Robotically advanced but easy for children to grasp the context...just speculating on potential creative thought processes!)that became the first true "anime'" show in the US, I think it would MOST likely be "Frederik L. Schodt" who will provide any validation of this...he is the person who adapted the Japanese story lines to be suitable for the American "elementary level schoolboy audience" it was targeted to be received by...and I sure was one of them!
I hope my brief history is not too long for this page to publish! My apologies if it is, if you need to edit it without losing context, I'm okay with it, I just hoped to ensure that proper crediting of this word fall on the possibly living originator or the popularizing of its use!
Daniel
I am going to suggest taking your heads out of the history books and look to the source of many recently added dictionary words' sources...the TV! LOL! Although I do not recall completely which episode this was, I have used this word since learning it when I was a mere 5 or so years old with my first being introduced to it while watching the original Astro Boy animated TV series, in which there was an episode he was being asked about his origins and first memories, and he replied with "The first thing I remembered was waking up in the Ministry of Science, on a busted up lab table. At the time, I had no idea what was going on. I was kind of…discombobulated." And I remember thinking how cool that BIG word was, and latched on to using it at every applicable opportunity.
Of course this is not necessarily the true source of the word, but certainly what brought it into the mainstream consciousness, and since these episodes were primarily based upon a 1950's comic book series, it would not surprise me if this were indeed the first ever use of it, since looking at the Dictionary.com timeline for its use, it shows exactly near the end of the 50's to begin being used, and then steadily rise in popularity of use as it CONTINUES to still to this day!!
When I used this word in an email and since my spell checker did not ask for override, I searched in surprise to find it was indeed a dictionary word, so I clicked on dictionary.com's etymology tab which was rather disappointing beyond the said timeline reported of its use which in turn brought me here to find out when this was officially became a "dictionary word" and when I saw all of these presumptuous but EDUCATED guesses of its formulation...
I thought the source of my first experience of this word's usage may contribute useful information to pinning an accurate origin or to find the actual formation of the word for its use.
Although... I don't think it will be found in "Astro Boy's origins", for being a Japanese language based iconic character, for obvious translation limitations, (which MAYBE, opened the way to substitute for a Japanese word lacking an English equivalent? If the original Japanese word translated only partially to disconcerting or something like this and and needed i t to sound "Robotically advanced but easy for children to grasp the context...just speculating on potential creative thought processes!)that became the first true "anime'" show in the US, I think it would MOST likely be "Frederik L. Schodt" who will provide any validation of this...he is the person who adapted the Japanese story lines to be suitable for the American "elementary level schoolboy audience" it was targeted to be received by...and I sure was one of them!
I hope my brief history is not too long for this page to publish! My apologies if it is, if you need to edit it without losing context, I'm okay with it, I just hoped to ensure that proper crediting of this word fall on the possibly living originator or the popularizing of its use!
Daniel
edited Mar 29 '15 at 20:29
answered Mar 29 '15 at 20:24
Daniel
111
111
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
add a comment |
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
1
1
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
This is at odds with @FumbleFingers' history and explanation ('It's a slang (originally American) word of unknown origin that goes back well over a century. Probably just a fanciful alliteration of discommode, discomfit, discompose, etc.') Hopefully, FF will give evidence backing these 3 claims (Am / orig unknown / over 100 yrs old), which will require this answer to be better supported. Unsupported answers are frowned upon nowadays on ELU.
– Edwin Ashworth
Mar 29 '15 at 23:44
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Here's a definition.
"the 'nineties' refers of course to the 1890s
Supplement to Rural Dialect of Grant County, Indiana, in the 'nineties
Waldo Lee McAtee, 1942 - Americanisms
discombobulate, v., put out of order, upset plans.
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RZQVAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgpMAA
... and here's a definition of sorts from a book written in 1893.
Half-hours with Jimmieboy
John Kendrick Bangs, R.H. Russell, 1893
"Well, here's a thing I don't know about," said Jimmieboy. "What is
'to alarm?'" "To frighten-to scare-to discombobulate."
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0_5DAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgxMAI
Before that we have the following from Going on a Mission by Paul Cobden, 1871
He told the cook what he'd done, and said it would 'perfectly discombobulate Maam Prole to miss her Bible...'
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=YT0wAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA32&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElazEh5bfAhWLQRUIHa_yDRAQ6AEIOjAE#v=onepage&q=%22discombobulate%22&f=false
I haven't been able to get back any further than that so I expect it is just a comical-sounding dialect word that someone either made up or mis-heard.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Here's a definition.
"the 'nineties' refers of course to the 1890s
Supplement to Rural Dialect of Grant County, Indiana, in the 'nineties
Waldo Lee McAtee, 1942 - Americanisms
discombobulate, v., put out of order, upset plans.
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RZQVAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgpMAA
... and here's a definition of sorts from a book written in 1893.
Half-hours with Jimmieboy
John Kendrick Bangs, R.H. Russell, 1893
"Well, here's a thing I don't know about," said Jimmieboy. "What is
'to alarm?'" "To frighten-to scare-to discombobulate."
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0_5DAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgxMAI
Before that we have the following from Going on a Mission by Paul Cobden, 1871
He told the cook what he'd done, and said it would 'perfectly discombobulate Maam Prole to miss her Bible...'
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=YT0wAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA32&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElazEh5bfAhWLQRUIHa_yDRAQ6AEIOjAE#v=onepage&q=%22discombobulate%22&f=false
I haven't been able to get back any further than that so I expect it is just a comical-sounding dialect word that someone either made up or mis-heard.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Here's a definition.
"the 'nineties' refers of course to the 1890s
Supplement to Rural Dialect of Grant County, Indiana, in the 'nineties
Waldo Lee McAtee, 1942 - Americanisms
discombobulate, v., put out of order, upset plans.
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RZQVAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgpMAA
... and here's a definition of sorts from a book written in 1893.
Half-hours with Jimmieboy
John Kendrick Bangs, R.H. Russell, 1893
"Well, here's a thing I don't know about," said Jimmieboy. "What is
'to alarm?'" "To frighten-to scare-to discombobulate."
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0_5DAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgxMAI
Before that we have the following from Going on a Mission by Paul Cobden, 1871
He told the cook what he'd done, and said it would 'perfectly discombobulate Maam Prole to miss her Bible...'
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=YT0wAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA32&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElazEh5bfAhWLQRUIHa_yDRAQ6AEIOjAE#v=onepage&q=%22discombobulate%22&f=false
I haven't been able to get back any further than that so I expect it is just a comical-sounding dialect word that someone either made up or mis-heard.
Here's a definition.
"the 'nineties' refers of course to the 1890s
Supplement to Rural Dialect of Grant County, Indiana, in the 'nineties
Waldo Lee McAtee, 1942 - Americanisms
discombobulate, v., put out of order, upset plans.
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=RZQVAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgpMAA
... and here's a definition of sorts from a book written in 1893.
Half-hours with Jimmieboy
John Kendrick Bangs, R.H. Russell, 1893
"Well, here's a thing I don't know about," said Jimmieboy. "What is
'to alarm?'" "To frighten-to scare-to discombobulate."
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=0_5DAQAAMAAJ&q=%22discombobulate%22&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiD1tLMh5bfAhW6VRUIHWfnDiU4ChDoAQgxMAI
Before that we have the following from Going on a Mission by Paul Cobden, 1871
He told the cook what he'd done, and said it would 'perfectly discombobulate Maam Prole to miss her Bible...'
https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=YT0wAAAAYAAJ&pg=PA32&dq=%22discombobulate%22&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwiElazEh5bfAhWLQRUIHa_yDRAQ6AEIOjAE#v=onepage&q=%22discombobulate%22&f=false
I haven't been able to get back any further than that so I expect it is just a comical-sounding dialect word that someone either made up or mis-heard.
edited Dec 10 at 20:22
answered Dec 10 at 20:15
chasly from UK
22.7k13068
22.7k13068
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
It's a joke word based on "discomfort", "disconcert" etc which are based on the french 'dis' meaning apart or opposite.
So if discomfort is undo-comfort and discombobulate is from the same sense you can have combolbulate as the opposite of whatever discombobulate is
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
It's a joke word based on "discomfort", "disconcert" etc which are based on the french 'dis' meaning apart or opposite.
So if discomfort is undo-comfort and discombobulate is from the same sense you can have combolbulate as the opposite of whatever discombobulate is
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
up vote
-1
down vote
It's a joke word based on "discomfort", "disconcert" etc which are based on the french 'dis' meaning apart or opposite.
So if discomfort is undo-comfort and discombobulate is from the same sense you can have combolbulate as the opposite of whatever discombobulate is
It's a joke word based on "discomfort", "disconcert" etc which are based on the french 'dis' meaning apart or opposite.
So if discomfort is undo-comfort and discombobulate is from the same sense you can have combolbulate as the opposite of whatever discombobulate is
answered Aug 18 '11 at 3:12
mgb
21.9k23687
21.9k23687
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
add a comment |
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
1
1
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
That etymology’s a little off: the prefix is from Old French des-, from Latin dis-, a prefix derived from Latin dis 'apart, asunder'. The original Latin sense survives in such words as disbud and dismember, in which the prefix is basically 'remove'.
– Brian M. Scott
Aug 18 '11 at 6:10
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
"Discombobulate" is similar to "flabbergasted" and "unwittingly".
These are examples of words that spontaneously arose--a phenomenon more frequently observed in the recent flash of social media and broadcast television. Small, even unintentional expressions can (and have) quickly caught on because they're likable and catchy.
It's the affair of language. Novelty bears offspring too.
Discombobulate is somewhat similar in concept to "dis-member" and "re-member", for while "combobulate" could come into usage, "recombobulate" is more likely since both relate a sense of "being done unto" rather than "doing unto another". Dismember and remember are not pure opposites, but conceptually relate since "memory can be altered and refashioned to serve slightly different purposes than it may have at the actual event" just as "dismemberment proves to alter and refashion so that service can no longer be rendered appropriately".
For example, one does not recapitulate in any related way that one capitulates, even though the capitalist may continue to capitalize on the edicts of the capital in a move toward capitulation for personal gain. Recapitulation will ever retain a personal note, for it is championed by the subjective, forgivable rendering. And so it may be with discombobulation--it is a personal event and, so far, may be unrelated to one's previous state.
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
"Discombobulate" is similar to "flabbergasted" and "unwittingly".
These are examples of words that spontaneously arose--a phenomenon more frequently observed in the recent flash of social media and broadcast television. Small, even unintentional expressions can (and have) quickly caught on because they're likable and catchy.
It's the affair of language. Novelty bears offspring too.
Discombobulate is somewhat similar in concept to "dis-member" and "re-member", for while "combobulate" could come into usage, "recombobulate" is more likely since both relate a sense of "being done unto" rather than "doing unto another". Dismember and remember are not pure opposites, but conceptually relate since "memory can be altered and refashioned to serve slightly different purposes than it may have at the actual event" just as "dismemberment proves to alter and refashion so that service can no longer be rendered appropriately".
For example, one does not recapitulate in any related way that one capitulates, even though the capitalist may continue to capitalize on the edicts of the capital in a move toward capitulation for personal gain. Recapitulation will ever retain a personal note, for it is championed by the subjective, forgivable rendering. And so it may be with discombobulation--it is a personal event and, so far, may be unrelated to one's previous state.
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
up vote
-1
down vote
"Discombobulate" is similar to "flabbergasted" and "unwittingly".
These are examples of words that spontaneously arose--a phenomenon more frequently observed in the recent flash of social media and broadcast television. Small, even unintentional expressions can (and have) quickly caught on because they're likable and catchy.
It's the affair of language. Novelty bears offspring too.
Discombobulate is somewhat similar in concept to "dis-member" and "re-member", for while "combobulate" could come into usage, "recombobulate" is more likely since both relate a sense of "being done unto" rather than "doing unto another". Dismember and remember are not pure opposites, but conceptually relate since "memory can be altered and refashioned to serve slightly different purposes than it may have at the actual event" just as "dismemberment proves to alter and refashion so that service can no longer be rendered appropriately".
For example, one does not recapitulate in any related way that one capitulates, even though the capitalist may continue to capitalize on the edicts of the capital in a move toward capitulation for personal gain. Recapitulation will ever retain a personal note, for it is championed by the subjective, forgivable rendering. And so it may be with discombobulation--it is a personal event and, so far, may be unrelated to one's previous state.
"Discombobulate" is similar to "flabbergasted" and "unwittingly".
These are examples of words that spontaneously arose--a phenomenon more frequently observed in the recent flash of social media and broadcast television. Small, even unintentional expressions can (and have) quickly caught on because they're likable and catchy.
It's the affair of language. Novelty bears offspring too.
Discombobulate is somewhat similar in concept to "dis-member" and "re-member", for while "combobulate" could come into usage, "recombobulate" is more likely since both relate a sense of "being done unto" rather than "doing unto another". Dismember and remember are not pure opposites, but conceptually relate since "memory can be altered and refashioned to serve slightly different purposes than it may have at the actual event" just as "dismemberment proves to alter and refashion so that service can no longer be rendered appropriately".
For example, one does not recapitulate in any related way that one capitulates, even though the capitalist may continue to capitalize on the edicts of the capital in a move toward capitulation for personal gain. Recapitulation will ever retain a personal note, for it is championed by the subjective, forgivable rendering. And so it may be with discombobulation--it is a personal event and, so far, may be unrelated to one's previous state.
edited Mar 15 '14 at 14:56
David M
14.2k64995
14.2k64995
answered Mar 15 '14 at 8:53
Peter Bassett
11
11
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
add a comment |
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
5
5
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
Unwittingly is no more a word that spontaneously arose than any other word in the English language. It's been around for a good seven centuries in more or less its present orthography, and nobody has the faintest chance of finding out how spontaneously or gradually it arose.
– Janus Bahs Jacquet
Jul 1 '14 at 23:43
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
to dismember someone you remove their limbs yes? so to member them - that does not mean to reattach the limbs does it. Remove the members (limbs) but you cannot then limb or member them and expect that to mean the opposite of dismember, so not every dis, has an exact opposite, there are some exceptions. I am inclined to think same exception applies to discombobulate.
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
to dismember someone you remove their limbs yes? so to member them - that does not mean to reattach the limbs does it. Remove the members (limbs) but you cannot then limb or member them and expect that to mean the opposite of dismember, so not every dis, has an exact opposite, there are some exceptions. I am inclined to think same exception applies to discombobulate.
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
up vote
-2
down vote
to dismember someone you remove their limbs yes? so to member them - that does not mean to reattach the limbs does it. Remove the members (limbs) but you cannot then limb or member them and expect that to mean the opposite of dismember, so not every dis, has an exact opposite, there are some exceptions. I am inclined to think same exception applies to discombobulate.
to dismember someone you remove their limbs yes? so to member them - that does not mean to reattach the limbs does it. Remove the members (limbs) but you cannot then limb or member them and expect that to mean the opposite of dismember, so not every dis, has an exact opposite, there are some exceptions. I am inclined to think same exception applies to discombobulate.
answered Jul 28 '13 at 19:40
artisan
1
1
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
add a comment |
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
and same exception applies to destroy, although yes des not dis.
– artisan
Jul 28 '13 at 19:41
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
http://www.definition-of.com/Combobulate
According to definition.com, COMBOBULATE is a word.
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
http://www.definition-of.com/Combobulate
According to definition.com, COMBOBULATE is a word.
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
add a comment |
up vote
-2
down vote
up vote
-2
down vote
http://www.definition-of.com/Combobulate
According to definition.com, COMBOBULATE is a word.
http://www.definition-of.com/Combobulate
According to definition.com, COMBOBULATE is a word.
answered Aug 26 '14 at 9:24
stacey
1
1
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
add a comment |
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
4
4
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
"Brevity is acceptable, but fuller explanations are better." (english.stackexchange.com/help/how-to-answer)
– Honza Zidek
Aug 26 '14 at 9:50
1
1
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
definition-of.com looks like it aggregates definitions from other sources, and doesn't seem to give citations. Can you find a more authoritative source?
– EleventhDoctor
Jul 28 '15 at 8:15
add a comment |
protected by tchrist♦ Jan 2 '16 at 2:27
Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?
4
Can you be "gruntled"?
– user362
Aug 18 '11 at 12:53
1
This doesn't help to explain why "combobulate" never became an actual word, but it gives a time frame for when "discombobulate" came into use. According to etymonline: 1834, Amer.Eng., fanciful coinage of a type popular then (originally discombobricate). Related: discombobulating; discombobulation.
– RGW1976
Aug 20 '11 at 23:15