Cfrtjryk

When I have a file a.txt and do ln -s a.txt b.txt, then I edit a.txt, a.txt's timestamp changed. But when I edit b.txt, b.txt doesn't change its timestamp. Only a.txt is changed. Why didn't b.txt's timestamp change. And a.txt's does.

Example:

$ ls -la

total 8

drwxr-xr-x  2 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:53 .

drwxr-x--- 37 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:53 ..

$ nano a.txt

$ ln -s a.txt b.txt

$ ls -la

total 12

drwxr-xr-x  2 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:54 .

drwxr-x--- 37 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:53 ..

-rw-r--r--  1 admin admin    4 nov  5 16:54 a.txt

lrwxrwxrwx  1 admin admin    5 nov  5 16:54 b.txt -> a.txt

$ echo wait a minute

wait a minute 

$ nano b.txt

$ ls -la

total 12

drwxr-xr-x  2 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:56 .

drwxr-x--- 37 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:53 ..

-rw-r--r--  1 admin admin    9 nov  5 16:56 a.txt

lrwxrwxrwx  1 admin admin    5 nov  5 16:54 b.txt -> a.txt 

$ echo wait a minute again

wait a minute again

$ nano a.txt

$ ls -la

total 12

drwxr-xr-x  2 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:58 .

drwxr-x--- 37 admin admin 4096 nov  5 16:53 ..

-rw-r--r--  1 admin admin   13 nov  5 16:58 a.txt

lrwxrwxrwx  1 admin admin    5 nov  5 16:54 b.txt -> a.txt

Look at this lines first:

-rw-r--r--  1 admin admin    4 nov  5 16:54 a.txt

lrwxrwxrwx  1 admin admin    5 nov  5 16:54 b.txt -> a.txt

Then look at this, only a.txt's date changed when I edited b.txt

-rw-r--r--  1 admin admin    9 nov  5 16:56 a.txt

lrwxrwxrwx  1 admin admin    5 nov  5 16:54 b.txt -> a.txt 

Okay I know that b.txt is a symlink to a.txt. So you edit a.txt.
But WHY didn't my OS change the date ONLY for a.txt. When I edit b.txt. It is much more useful to also change the date of b.txt.

But then you also can say that directory's won't change its date when I file is edited in the directory (i edited a file, and i used the directory). The directory is used to edit the file in it. But the os does change the directory date when i edit a file in it

Because when you ask to edit b.txt you edit a.txt, the link is unaltered: Traversing the link does not change it.

Trying to access a link accesses the file that it points to (or the eventual file that is pointed to, the link may point to a link that points to a link that eventually point to a file/directory/something-else). Links are only access by using special link access routines. In addition soft-links can not be edited (only created and removed).

The answer:

1. When you open a symlink to a file, you exactly did open the symlink, read the text in the symlink (the link) out, close it and opens the file where it links to. So that means when you edit it. You never edited the symlink file.




2. Directory's contains another directorys or pointers to file like so:

This is the data on the beginning of the disk.

A 16:44:

   -- B 17:18:

       -- C 3kb: 15754

       -- D 4kb: 26544

   -- E 18:10:

       -- F 6kb: 16754

       -- G 8kb: 27544

When you edit a file in a DIRECTORY. the filesize is changed, the date is changed (and more attributes). And that is changed in the directory information. So you also edited the directory data (size, date...). And so is the directory changed.

Result:

This is the data on the beginning of the disk after editing C.

A 18:20:

   -- B 18:20:

       -- C 8kb: 15754

       -- D 4kb: 26544

   -- E 18:10:

       -- F 6kb: 16754

       -- G 8kb: 27544