Crop duster to F-16 Pilot - how feasible?












3














In the movie Independence Day, one of the characters ends up saving the day by flying an F-16 (or some type of fighter-jet) into the Alien Mothership.



That character's only previous experience flying was crop-dusting with a small crop-dusting plane (and we can assume he wasn't necessarily the best pilot there, but was competent).



While I understand there are holes, and exaggerations, etc. in the movie, I was curious - Could you train a pilot who has only flown small crop-dusting planes to successfully take off and fly a fighter jet within say, 1 month?



Or for all practical purposes would it be better to simply not use that pilot (because they might crash the plane on takeoff, etc.)?



(I'm unsure if this is a better fit over on Aviation SE or here...)










share|improve this question



























    3














    In the movie Independence Day, one of the characters ends up saving the day by flying an F-16 (or some type of fighter-jet) into the Alien Mothership.



    That character's only previous experience flying was crop-dusting with a small crop-dusting plane (and we can assume he wasn't necessarily the best pilot there, but was competent).



    While I understand there are holes, and exaggerations, etc. in the movie, I was curious - Could you train a pilot who has only flown small crop-dusting planes to successfully take off and fly a fighter jet within say, 1 month?



    Or for all practical purposes would it be better to simply not use that pilot (because they might crash the plane on takeoff, etc.)?



    (I'm unsure if this is a better fit over on Aviation SE or here...)










    share|improve this question

























      3












      3








      3







      In the movie Independence Day, one of the characters ends up saving the day by flying an F-16 (or some type of fighter-jet) into the Alien Mothership.



      That character's only previous experience flying was crop-dusting with a small crop-dusting plane (and we can assume he wasn't necessarily the best pilot there, but was competent).



      While I understand there are holes, and exaggerations, etc. in the movie, I was curious - Could you train a pilot who has only flown small crop-dusting planes to successfully take off and fly a fighter jet within say, 1 month?



      Or for all practical purposes would it be better to simply not use that pilot (because they might crash the plane on takeoff, etc.)?



      (I'm unsure if this is a better fit over on Aviation SE or here...)










      share|improve this question













      In the movie Independence Day, one of the characters ends up saving the day by flying an F-16 (or some type of fighter-jet) into the Alien Mothership.



      That character's only previous experience flying was crop-dusting with a small crop-dusting plane (and we can assume he wasn't necessarily the best pilot there, but was competent).



      While I understand there are holes, and exaggerations, etc. in the movie, I was curious - Could you train a pilot who has only flown small crop-dusting planes to successfully take off and fly a fighter jet within say, 1 month?



      Or for all practical purposes would it be better to simply not use that pilot (because they might crash the plane on takeoff, etc.)?



      (I'm unsure if this is a better fit over on Aviation SE or here...)







      independence-day






      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question











      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question










      asked 5 hours ago









      BruceWayne

      311411




      311411






















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          5














          The character of Russell Casse is currently employed crop-dusting, but this is not his only previous experience flying.



          He is a former F-4 fighter pilot and fought in the Vietnam War.



          While getting competent in any plane requires some familiarity and training, its a far more likely conversion from one fighter jet to another, than from a propeller driven crop duster to an F-16.



          From one copy of the script:




          Well, I'm, uh, Russell Casse, sir.
          And, uh... after 'Nam,
          I got into crop-dusting.
          And, uh... been doing that ever since.




          Which at the very least implies heavily that he has combat flying experience and transferred to crop dusting after he got out of service, even if there is no specific mention of the F-4.






          share|improve this answer























          • Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago










          • Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
            – iandotkelly
            5 hours ago










          • I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago








          • 1




            Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago






          • 1




            @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago



















          3














          All Russell said was:




          "I can fly, I'm a pilot"




          But in an alternate ending Russell flew is biplane into the alien ship...











          share|improve this answer





























            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes








            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            5














            The character of Russell Casse is currently employed crop-dusting, but this is not his only previous experience flying.



            He is a former F-4 fighter pilot and fought in the Vietnam War.



            While getting competent in any plane requires some familiarity and training, its a far more likely conversion from one fighter jet to another, than from a propeller driven crop duster to an F-16.



            From one copy of the script:




            Well, I'm, uh, Russell Casse, sir.
            And, uh... after 'Nam,
            I got into crop-dusting.
            And, uh... been doing that ever since.




            Which at the very least implies heavily that he has combat flying experience and transferred to crop dusting after he got out of service, even if there is no specific mention of the F-4.






            share|improve this answer























            • Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago










            • Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
              – iandotkelly
              5 hours ago










            • I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago








            • 1




              Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago






            • 1




              @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago
















            5














            The character of Russell Casse is currently employed crop-dusting, but this is not his only previous experience flying.



            He is a former F-4 fighter pilot and fought in the Vietnam War.



            While getting competent in any plane requires some familiarity and training, its a far more likely conversion from one fighter jet to another, than from a propeller driven crop duster to an F-16.



            From one copy of the script:




            Well, I'm, uh, Russell Casse, sir.
            And, uh... after 'Nam,
            I got into crop-dusting.
            And, uh... been doing that ever since.




            Which at the very least implies heavily that he has combat flying experience and transferred to crop dusting after he got out of service, even if there is no specific mention of the F-4.






            share|improve this answer























            • Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago










            • Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
              – iandotkelly
              5 hours ago










            • I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago








            • 1




              Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago






            • 1




              @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago














            5












            5








            5






            The character of Russell Casse is currently employed crop-dusting, but this is not his only previous experience flying.



            He is a former F-4 fighter pilot and fought in the Vietnam War.



            While getting competent in any plane requires some familiarity and training, its a far more likely conversion from one fighter jet to another, than from a propeller driven crop duster to an F-16.



            From one copy of the script:




            Well, I'm, uh, Russell Casse, sir.
            And, uh... after 'Nam,
            I got into crop-dusting.
            And, uh... been doing that ever since.




            Which at the very least implies heavily that he has combat flying experience and transferred to crop dusting after he got out of service, even if there is no specific mention of the F-4.






            share|improve this answer














            The character of Russell Casse is currently employed crop-dusting, but this is not his only previous experience flying.



            He is a former F-4 fighter pilot and fought in the Vietnam War.



            While getting competent in any plane requires some familiarity and training, its a far more likely conversion from one fighter jet to another, than from a propeller driven crop duster to an F-16.



            From one copy of the script:




            Well, I'm, uh, Russell Casse, sir.
            And, uh... after 'Nam,
            I got into crop-dusting.
            And, uh... been doing that ever since.




            Which at the very least implies heavily that he has combat flying experience and transferred to crop dusting after he got out of service, even if there is no specific mention of the F-4.







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 5 hours ago

























            answered 5 hours ago









            iandotkelly

            34.5k8138162




            34.5k8138162












            • Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago










            • Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
              – iandotkelly
              5 hours ago










            • I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago








            • 1




              Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago






            • 1




              @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago


















            • Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago










            • Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
              – iandotkelly
              5 hours ago










            • I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
              – BruceWayne
              5 hours ago








            • 1




              Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago






            • 1




              @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
              – MissouriSpartan
              5 hours ago
















            Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago




            Ohh, that makes sense! I haven't seen the movie in a while and forgot (or never caught on) he was a former military pilot.
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago












            Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
            – iandotkelly
            5 hours ago




            Yeah, though I'm trying to track down specific in-movie quotes to support that - at the very least he is a stereotype of a PTSD afflicted vietnam vet.
            – iandotkelly
            5 hours ago












            I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago






            I've seen the movie zillions of times, and I can't recall him mentioning he was a former pilot - except maybe when he volunteered, they asked if he had experience. I'd assume he'd say "Vietnam, F-4s", instead of "Crop dusting all day!", but will have to re-watch to make sure. (I'm not saying it's not true, just can't remember the source of that fact).
            – BruceWayne
            5 hours ago






            1




            1




            Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago




            Side note! If you watch another ending of the movie, he's flying an old bi-plane with a bomb on it into the mouth of the mother ship instead of the fighter jet.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago




            1




            1




            @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago




            @iandotkelly , that was the original ending, technically, wasn't it? And then they added the 'alternate' ending of him being in an F/A-18 which eventually "morphed" into being accepted as the normal ending? I thought...........could be wrong.
            – MissouriSpartan
            5 hours ago











            3














            All Russell said was:




            "I can fly, I'm a pilot"




            But in an alternate ending Russell flew is biplane into the alien ship...











            share|improve this answer


























              3














              All Russell said was:




              "I can fly, I'm a pilot"




              But in an alternate ending Russell flew is biplane into the alien ship...











              share|improve this answer
























                3












                3








                3






                All Russell said was:




                "I can fly, I'm a pilot"




                But in an alternate ending Russell flew is biplane into the alien ship...











                share|improve this answer












                All Russell said was:




                "I can fly, I'm a pilot"




                But in an alternate ending Russell flew is biplane into the alien ship...




















                share|improve this answer












                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer










                answered 5 hours ago









                Skooba

                8,0294462




                8,0294462















                    Popular posts from this blog

                    Morgemoulin

                    Scott Moir

                    Souastre